Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Pamela Burns's avatar

In R.R.Reno’s writings included in your column, he says the virus doesn’t pose “an extreme threat”. I think hundreds of thousands of US deaths are pretty extreme. I agree with you that requiring masks in a close indoor setting such as church or theaters or grocery stores as well as stressing the importance of vaccinations even to the point of mandates is a reasonable public health solution. God gave us the ability to use our brains to develop science snd scientific methods to aid our personal and societal health. It seems irresponsible to do otherwise. It also seems that if we practice loving our neighbor as ourselves we would want to employ protections for the common good.

Expand full comment
bob fryling's avatar

Mark, I agree that there are trends of “healthism” in the country. But I don’t think a concern about a pandemic that has killed more than 650,000 Americans plus millions more world-wide can in any reasonable way be considered “as spiritually corrupting as fixations on wealth and material consumption.” Jesus warned against the dangers of mammon but not against caring for the sick and loving one’s neighbor!

I do wonder how Reno can say that vaccines are only moderately effective when those that aren’t vaccinated are eleven times more likely to die than those that are vaccinated. I also don’t understand how such a pro-life advocate like Reno can be so cavalier about real and potential loss of life and even blame those who do care about saving lives as having disordered preoccupations. It seems like he is speaking more from a political rather than from either a medical or biblical perspective.

I believe that vaccine mandates that have been carefully studied, evaluated and recommended by the CDC and FDA are not extreme measures any more than requiring polio and small pox vaccines are. My aunt died of polio before a vaccine was developed so I have been personally touched by death among the unvaccinated. I am also glad that millions of lives have been saved because of this polio public health vaccine mandate. Why ae COVID vaccines any different?

To go back to Reno’s concern about “disordered affections”, I would add to the list of concerns an idolatry of independence and individualism that doesn’t seem to care about the health and welfare of the broader society. In the context of Jeremiah’s familiar exhortation, God’s people should care about the health and welfare of the society in which they live. So we indeed should be cheerleaders for anything like vaccines that can save an abundance of human lives. Healthism is not nearly as great a spiritual threat as a lack of compassion for the past and future victims of the pandemic.

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts